My younger self believed that you could change people's minds with
logical arguments. With age and wisdom, I do not believe this to be true
anymore. There are of course people who can be rationally convinced to change
their minds. You can see it happening in real time. Because I see it so rarely,
I find it a bit unbelievable when it happens. It's a bit like when a person
can't see and you switch on the lights. They can see now. It makes you happy
too. But there is the other situation where the person is blind. No amount of
turning on the lights or increasing the glare is going to help. They will not
see because they lack vision. It's got nothing to do with light.
In a way I have become a lot more resigned towards the latter
group of people. I don't make it my responsibility to convince people of
anything anymore. I feel a lot lighter. I also hold the possibility of being
wrong myself a bit more consciously. It's one thing to be wrong but at least I
am not converting anybody. I want to be proved wrong if I am—with logic and
evidence of course. A few people who know me sometimes tell me
"jokingly" that I always seem to be right. But if I ask them to show
me how I am wrong, in what instance, in what way, etc, they backtrack. They are
not the ones who can turn on the light for me and they know it.
I make a distinction between those who are self-aware about their
limited vision and those who lack even that reflexive capacity. With the
self-aware there is an openness to the fact that they might not really be able
to see quite that far though they are trying. It's like the blind man who goes
to the doctor to check their sight and get help. They want to overcome the
limitation. Their honesty inclines me to make an effort with them. The
non-self-aware are smug in their ignorance because they do not even have the
reflexive capacity to diagnose it as such. They can't be helped because they do
not believe they need it. The conclusion I have come to is that it's best to
leave them to their devices. The consequences are bound to catch up eventually.
Whether they are able to recognize them for what they are, your guess is as
good as mine.
posted by Sylvia D'souza at 10:42 pm
0 comments