To Be or Not To Be

A little kingdom I possess,
Where thoughts and feelings dwell;
And very hard the task I find
Of governing it well.
~ Louisa May Alcott

...that more or less describes my situation!

~A Wise Man Said~

It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it.
~ Aristotle

Thursday, November 19, 2026
 

Among the many raging debates around AI, there is one that completely baffles me. It gives me 'the emperor's new clothes' vibe. I can't but wonder how so many seemingly sensible and intelligent people can collectively and seriously weigh in on the question of whether AI has 'consciousness'. It's almost the same, from my perspective, as asking if my fridge or TV or printer or the Google search engine has consciousness. We could keep the point about whether AI is useful or not, harmful or not, aside for the moment because this matter of 'consciousness' does not depend on it. I am thrilled and exasperated by my printer too from time to time, as no doubt everybody is. Sometimes it throws up incomprehensible messages that I have a hard time decoding. Though it does invoke emotions in me that people do many a times, I have never considered even for one moment whether it might have 'consciousness'. What is it about AI that makes sane people pose this bonkers question...?

The one difference, as I see it, between all these lifeless things and programmed objects and AI, which is also a lifeless thing and programmed object, is that AI has language. Not the fixed limited error code language of a printer or the static list of websites thrown up by Google—neither of these textual outputs 'talk to' you. They are just blobs of text put out by the machines. In contrast, what AI puts out has this quality that we have so far associated only with human beings. To have a 'conversation' with us, or more accurately make us feel like it is having a conversation with us. Not just throw text messages without any context at us. Language is more than just language though. When I encounter a person whose language I do not know, such as say Chinese, there is a certain distance between us. The moment they speak a language I know, such as English, it is as if suddenly we encounter each other on a footing we couldn't earlier. We are opened up to each other. There is a possibility of accessing each other's inner worlds or each other's consciousness in a sense. When AI 'speaks to' me in a language I know, it gives me a false sense of access to something that heretofore could only have been a human being. When it gives me a clear solution couched in emotional language, though my conscious mind knows it's no different from the random code from a printer (except that it works), unconsciously I could be taken into a reciprocal mode that only close human beings so far could produce.

But the question of whether AI has consciousness and whether AI can mimic entities that have consciousness and thereby fool you, are two different questions? Ultimately there is nothing about AI that makes it any different from the TV or fridge or printer. What it produces has nothing to do with human capacities such as 'thinking' or 'feeling' or 'experiencing' or 'sensing' or 'learning'. Its most elegant answer to a human problem or the most beautiful piece of artwork are only elegant and beautiful in so far as they mine into a vast pool of humanly developed work. One could debate whether these outputs are actually elegant or beautiful or one could debate whether AI should be allowed to contaminate the pool of historically generated human work or any number of other things... but I don't see how whether AI has a 'consciousness' or can grow a 'consciousness' can be a matter of debate! All it seems to do is divert attention from the harder questions.